Hardstark cohosts a podcast with Ward called Slumber Party with Alie & Georgia, through Feral Audio. In 2016, the series began airing on Fullscreen. In 2016, she and Karen Kilgariff co-created the "My Favorite Murder" podcast, which is also produced and distributed by Feral Audio. Beginning in May 2016, it achieved very high ratings on the iTunes comedy podcast rankings, appearing as high as number one. As of August 8, 2017, it was ranked #3 on the iTunes comedy charts. In its 2016 year-end issue, Entertainment Weekly ranked it the second best podcast of the year.
