Despite being engaged to I Love New York season 1 winner Patrick "Tango" Hunter, Pollard's engagement was soon called off. Afterwards, Pollard signed on for a second season of I Love New York. When asked if Patterson would make an appearance, pollard responded; "Definitely, definitely. I couldn't do it without her. She's going to come down and make sure everything's in order. You know how she does it. She's going to be there for a large chunk of the show, actually." While most of the contestants were picked by Pollard, Patterson picked 5 men called the "mama's boys". Patterson had strong opinions about the other guys, that she loudly expressed. She would even later label one man a "freak" and scream at a little person. I Love New York 2 premiered on October 8, 2007 and the finale aired on December 17.