The film expands on the lore introduced in the earliest films, with it being described by Paul Taylor as a "jumping off point" for a sequel that " ... could continue the story that it tells because it's a true Hellraiser script with a beginning, a middle, and a sort of ambiguous end. And these new characters they introduced could be in Future Hellraiser films." The actor elucidated that, should a sequel go into production, he would want to return as Pinhead but would also applaud a larger budgeted reboot starring Doug Bradley. Tunnicliffe said of Judgment's ending, "My attitude is that if he's the king of the castle, then what hurts Pinhead? Taking away his crown. Maybe if he is bored and it's become a drudgery, maybe being banished to the earthly realm and then finding his way back would make him more aggressive; make him come back with a vengeance." He stated that the possibility of a Judgment sequel is "purely a question of fan reaction and economics." Addressing the themes of pain and pleasure in the 1987 film, the Director specified "Honestly that is the stuff I love the most. Unfortunately, the people holding the pink slip on the movie really struggle with those elements, I was able to get some pretty strange stuff past them on this one, but the heavy sadomasochistic stuff might have to wait until they have more faith in me." He stated that he had no particular idea for a sequel, spin-off, or follow-up of any kind when developing the film, "I have thought about it afterwards, what I think would be great fun. Maybe a new Cenobite ruler comes in, and this Cenobite's not doing a great job. And underhandedly, the Auditor is leaving a trail of breadcrumbs for the guy who is Pinhead to find his way back, and he gets pulled in. And then it's like, he turns up, and it's like a showdown between the newly born Pinhead and this guy who's taken over his mantle." He later went on that if such a showdown took place, he would intend on bringing back the Cenobites seen in the original film, particularly the Female Cenobite and Butterball Cenobite.