On May 10, 2003, Lonstein married Joshua Gruss, son of financier Martin D. Gruss and grandson of financier and philanthropist Joseph S. Gruss. Joshua Gruss is a Partner at Gruss & Co., a private investment firm based in New York City, and CEO of Round Hill Music. They have three children, a daughter, Sienna, born in 2005 who now Models for her, and twins, Angelica and Joseph Colby, born in 2012. The pair divorced in 2014.