In 1996, McCormack appeared on Broadway at the Criterion Center Stage Right as a member of the ensemble in a revival of the drama play Summer and Smoke (1948) by Tennessee Williams, produced by The Roundabout Theatre Company. He has also appeared in two Off-Broadway theatre productions, Chinese Friends and The Long Christmas Ride Home. On January 18, 2018, it was announced that Toy Story 4 would be written by Stephany Folsom, replacing the original Writers, Rashida Jones and McCormack, who withdrew from the project in November 2017.