On December 17, 1938, Woodbury married actor and Producer Henry Wilcoxon, with whom she had three daughters: Wendy Joan Robert (born 1939), Heather Ann (born 1947, named after Heather Angel) and Cecilia Dawn "CiCi" (1950, named after Cecil B. DeMille). They divorced in 1969. After the marriage, according to film critic Don Daynard, she "continued her career but never graduated from the minors", featuring in such films as Barnyard Follies, In Old Cheyenne and Brenda Starr, Reporter.